Case Study: A Violation of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act

Case Study: A Violation of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act

Always practice within the law.

A mortgage brokerage firm had an arrangement with a lender who paid the firm based on the number of referrals received. The brokerage firm was requiring clients to obtain a mortgage pre-approval from this specific lender, even if the client had already received pre-approval from another lender.

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), this is a violation of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA). RESPA prohibits real estate agents and brokerage firms from recommending settlement services, such as title insurance, appraisals, inspections, and loan origination to consumers in exchange for payment from service providers. This activity is known as an illegal kickback scheme.

Mistake:

The brokerage firm should have known that it is illegal to make or accept payments for mortgage referrals.

Result:

The lender and brokerage company were ordered by the CFPB to pay civil penalties and consumer compensation.

Prevention:

Never make or accept payments for referrals, as it is illegal. To ensure you are always working within the law, familiarize yourself with RESPA and keep up to date on additions and/or amendments to the law.

The Pearl Insurance errors and omissions policy adds defense cost coverage, by endorsement, for CFPB complaints; however, RESPA violations are not covered. It should be noted that fines, penalties, and sanctions are not covered by errors and omissions policies. Review your policy to make sure you have proper coverage in place for your business.

This article was produced in conjunction with XL Catlin and is not to be taken as legal advice.

a cartoon illustration of houses in a variety of shapes and colors
Real Estate

Understanding Fair Housing Discrimination and Staying Compliant

Fair housing laws aren’t just legal guidelines—they’re cornerstones of ethical real estate practice. In 2025, there have been increased violations tied to housing discrimination, which has caught many agents and brokers off guard. These complaints can lead to costly settlements

Read More »
How Social Inflation Could Leave Your Policy Limits Behind
Accountants

How Social Inflation Could Leave Your Policy Limits Behind

The world is changing every day, especially the world of insurance. While traditional inflation has grabbed headlines in recent years, there’s another form that could quietly put your accounting firm at risk: social inflation. This hidden factor has led to

Read More »